• Robert Winslow

    on July 16, 2008

    These are the diagnostic interpretations of Susan Allerton, Durango Bird Club
    Mystery hummingbird thoughts:
    Yesterday, I had a chance to view the hummingbird coming to the
    Pfeiffer's feeders. (The Pfeiffer's place is only about 3/4 mile
    from where I live.) In addition, I carefully studied the excellent
    photos that Marsha Pfeiffer and Robert Winslow took. After
    consulting several references, I concluded that the bird is either a
    Black-chinned Hummingbird or a Ruby-throated Hummingbird because the
    inner primaries are much narrower than the outer primaries on those
    two species. That seemed to hold true for the bird at the Pfeiffer's
    house. That determination narrowed it down to one of those two
    species, both in the genus Archilochus.
    Tail differences and outer primary differences seem to be the
    key field marks for separating Black-chinned Hummingbird from Ruby-
    throated Hummingbird. On the Ruby-throated, the outer
    primary "tapers to a narrow rounded tip". [The outer primary (p10)
    is of a narrower width that the next primary (P9).] On Black-chinned
    Hummingbirds, the 2 outer primaries are of similar width. The outer
    primary on the Durango hummingbird seems to be a similar width to the
    next primary. That would agree with an ID of Black-chinned
    Hummingbird. As for the tail differences, the tail on the Black-
    chinned Hummingbird is slightly shorter than the Ruby-throated
    Hummingbird. The best way to distinguish the tails of the two
    species would be to observe the closed tail from the back. If the
    graduated lengths of the tail tips are visible, you'd be able to
    count 3 or 4 tail tips on the folded tail. 3 tail tips would
    indicate Black-chinned; 4 tail tips would indicate a Ruby-throated.
    I believe that the 2 outer tail feathers would not visible on the
    folded tail. If true, 3 tails tips would be visible, indicating
    Black-chinned. All of the above information was gathered from the
    following sources: Sheri Williamson's Hummingbirds of North America,
    Hummingbirds of North America by Steve Howell, and Identification
    Guide to North American Birds by Peter Pyle. The last reference
    indicated that the shape of the 6th primary is another significant
    way of separating the two. That primary feather is slightly less
    attenuate & more rounded on a Black-chinned Hummingbird than a Ruby-
    throated. The 6th primary shape (visible on a couple of the photos)
    seems correct for Black-chinned Hummingbird. Consequently, all the
    field marks seem to be pointing to Black-chinned Hummingbird for me.
    However, I'd really be interested in hearing what the hummingbird
    experts think.
    Many thanks to Marsha and Bob Pfeiffer for reporting this
    interesting bird. I also appreciate receiving all those excellent
    photos from Marsha Pfeiffer and Robert Winslow. All the finer
    details of the bird are much easier to study in the photographs!

All images are copyrighted.  You are not authorized to use any image without the express written consent of Robert Winslow